This post is inspired by a someone who wrote me interested if I produced a number-based version of the Wine Vintage Card. He felt the 'smiley faces' might prove embarrassing should a wine professional see them. Actually he said 'sommelier', but I assume he meant anyone one feels the need to put on wine airs around. We have all felt the need to put on airs at one time or another. Unfortunately, it seems part and parcel of the wine experience.
My response elucidates many of my original thoughts behind creating the card as well as a bit of history as to how it came about. Hope you enjoy it!
Dear Sir,
I appreciate your thoughts. The card has been a long time in production. What you see here comes after a long journey - carrying a folded up 8.5 x 11 vintage chart, printed out from the web, in my wallet to constructing a wallet version of my own (basically a numbers-based miniaturized version printed out on paper.) After several more botched iterations I happened upon the present concept you see for sale on
my site. There's an
iPhone / iPod Touch version now too.
The earlier versions of
the card failed in significant ways, seeing my goal of creating a simple and portable wine rating system that anyone could interpret and use in just about any wine-related situation. As refinement of the concept progressed, I discovered a small number of surprising (at the time) facts that significantly altered my direction.
1. The vast majority of people are completely disinterested in carrying around a wine rating system based on numbers. In this case, numbers are boring and show too much variation and ambiguity to allow quick and decisive decisions. When I moved from numbers to modern, cute, and intuitive emoticons, viola, everyone wanted one and people started to use them religiously.
2. People want the wine buying experience to be fun - and for many it's not. So many regions, varietals, and vintages - how do you bring it all together? Emoticons were the key for getting people to relax and start exploring. I created this tool so that anyone, regardless of wine knowledge, could
relax, have fun, and experience a little more control and power when
buying wine.
3. Numbers are difficult to interpret and offer too many possibilities when trying make quick decisions. A grid of numbers between 1 - 100 or even 1 - 5, seem incongruous to most people when related to a beverage such as wine. They want the experience to be easy and enjoyable. Now a big smiley face compared to frowning one, that's obvious. People have no difficulty deciphering and comparing facial expressions.
4. People want the system to work where they actually buy and drink wine. In retrospect, there's a no-brainer. Unlike any other wine rating system, the
Wine Vintage Card is specifically designed to
be used quickly, easily, and discreetly in any wine buying situation –-
in busy restaurants, dimly-lit wine bars, high-pressure wine shops and
bewildering supermarkets.
I carry and use
the card because it's easy to interpret and read as well as durable and easy to take out and put away. And it also works. I have on occasion cringed a little when a server or sommelier spotted it in a restaurant. But to my surprise, most wine professionals love them. Today's wine professionals are cool with anything that gets people to deepen their wine experience. Of course, I have run into a few who seem threatened by the whole idea...but they are the exception not the rule -- and I assume they'd feel that way about a number-based card as well.
Thank you for your interest.
WineVintageCard.comNote: One thing I neglected to mention to him. Paradoxically, pulling a wine
rating system covered with smiley faces out of my pocket, even in the
finest of fine dining situations, brings the whole situation down to earth and reminds me, over and over again, that really, we are all just here to have fun.